Theft by Extortion

Strategic Defense Against Theft by Extortion Charges

Theft by extortion is one of the most serious theft-related offenses under Pennsylvania law because it involves allegations of threats or coercion to obtain money, property, or services. A conviction can lead to felony charges, significant prison time, and a permanent criminal record that follows you for life.

At Sheridan Lawyers, we aggressively defend clients accused of theft by extortion in Chester County, Bucks County, Delaware County, and Montgomery County. We know these cases often involve complex facts and high stakes—and we fight to protect your future.

What Is Theft by Extortion?

Under 18 Pa.C.S. § 3923, theft by extortion occurs when someone unlawfully obtains property from another by threatening to:

• Inflict bodily injury on the victim or another person

• Accuse someone of a crime

• Expose secrets that could harm a person’s reputation

• Take or withhold action as an official (or influence an official’s actions)

• Cause any other harm that would coerce the victim into giving up property

Importantly, the property does not have to be taken by physical force; the threat itself, if proven, is enough for the prosecution to charge extortion.

Penalties for Theft by Extortion

Penalties depend on the type of threat and the value of the property involved:

• Often charged as a felony of the second or third degree

• Penalties may include up to 10 years in prison, significant fines, restitution, and probation

In addition, a conviction can lead to:

• A permanent criminal record

• Damaged reputation and employment consequences

• Loss of professional licenses or immigration status

How Sheridan Lawyers Defends Theft by Extortion Cases

These cases rely heavily on intent and evidence of threats, both of which can be challenged. Our defense strategies may include:

• Arguing there was no threat or coercion, only a lawful demand (e.g., a civil dispute mistaken for extortion)

• Challenging witness credibility and the interpretation of statements or communications

• Contesting whether the alleged threat rises to the legal standard of extortion

• Filing motions to suppress unlawfully obtained recordings, messages, or other evidence

Where possible, we also negotiate to reduce or dismiss charges or secure alternative programs like ARD.

Why Immediate Legal Counsel Is Crucial

Theft by extortion charges are taken extremely seriously by law enforcement and prosecutors. Do not make any statements or try to explain your side of the story to investigators without an attorney. Early intervention gives us the best chance to control the narrative and protect your rights.